VS
Compare the Tesla Model Y vs BYD Sealin our electric car comparison tool
Performance and driving: BYD Seal or Tesla Model Y, which model is the most dynamic?
How much power and acceleration for the BYD Seal and Tesla Model Y?
La BYD Seal stands out for its impressive performance. In its top-of-the-range version with all-wheel drive, it develops up to 324bhp. The most powerful versions accelerate from 0 to 100 km/h in 5.9 seconds, offering a dynamic driving experience. The BYD Seal UFor its part, the car offers electric variants with power ratings ranging from 218 to 324bhp, and 0-100kph acceleration times of between 5.9 and 9.6 seconds, depending on the model.
The Tesla Model Y, on the other hand, outperforms the BYD Seal in terms of pure performance. It offers all-electric versions with power ratings ranging from 299 to 534 bhp. Its fastest version, the Performance, accelerates from 0 to 100 kph in just 3.7 seconds, delivering blistering acceleration. The Model Y's impressive torque of up to 660 Nm contributes to its exceptional performance. Even the Grande Autonomy with all-wheel drive boasts impressive figures, with a top speed of 217 km/h.
Which car offers the best handling and driving experience?
The Tesla Model Y stands out for its handling and dynamic behaviour. Its firmer damping gives it a sharper, more precise ride, which is particularly appreciated during sporty driving. The Level 2 driving aids work well, although the Auto Pilot mode can sometimes be unreliable. The Model Y is also more fuel-efficient, with an average fuel consumption of 16.9 kWh/100 km for the Long Range version with all-wheel drive, which translates into a greater real-world range.
By contrast, the BYD Seal U is less sporty and more comfortable to drive. Its steering is described as numb and its suspension is softer, which may detract from the sporty feel but improves everyday ride comfort. Handling is not typically European, with a body that can wobble considerably during dynamic driving. However, for those who prefer a quiet ride, the Seal U offers a pleasant and comfortable travel experience. It should be noted that the BYD Seal (not U) offers a better driving experience, with a very pleasant feel from the first few kilometres and power and handling that guarantee real comfort on the road.
Autonomy and recharging: BYD Seal vs Tesla Model Y, which goes further?
What is the real range of the BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y?
The BYD Seal boasts an impressive WLTP range of 520 to 570 km, depending on the version. However, the actual range seems to be less. During a test drive, the first 100 km consumed 25% of diesel. batteryThis would give a range of around 400 km and fuel consumption of 19 kWh/100 km in mixed conditions. These figures suggest that the BYD Seal's real range would be closer to 400-450 km in everyday use.
La Tesla Model Yoffers a WLTP range varying from 455 km for the rear-wheel drive version to 568 km for the new version. Tesla Model Y Juniper Long range. In real-world conditions, the Model Y stands out for its remarkable efficiency. On the motorway at 130 km/h, it consumes an average of 18.4 kWh/100 km, giving it a real-world range of over 300 km. By reducing speed to 120 km/h, consumption drops to 16.9 kWh/100 km, increasing range by 27 km. In the city, the Model Y is even more efficient, consuming just 13.5 kWh/100 km, giving it a potential range of 422 km.
Recharging time and compatibility with rapid charging stations
The BYD Seal is equipped with an 82 kWh battery and can be recharged in direct current up to 150 kW. Although this charging power is lower than that of some competitors, it is still within the market norm. BYD claims a recharge time of 26 minutes to go from 30 to 80% of charge on a fast terminalThis is the case for both rear-wheel drive and all-wheel drive versions.
The Tesla Model Y, particularly the rear-wheel drive version, has an official charging capacity of 170 kW. In real-life tests, it was found that it could go from 10 to 80% of charge in just 23 minutes. What's more, the Model Y benefits from Tesla's extensive Supercharger network, which is a significant advantage for long journeys. The new Tesla Model Y Juniper version, which will be launched in 2025, even promises fast-charging capacity, enabling it to recover up to 454 km of range in 24 minutes.
It is important to note that this charging performance may vary depending on various factors such as the outside temperature, the state of the battery and the actual power delivered by the charging point.
Design and technology : BYD Seal or Tesla Model Y, which car appeals most?
Exterior design comparison: is the BYD Seal more elegant than the Tesla Model Y?
The BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y offer distinct aesthetic approaches, each with its own strengths. The BYD Seal has a sleek, modern design, with a front end that echoes the styling of the Seal saloon, including all-LED headlamps. Its silhouette is more massive than that of the Model Y, with longer overhangs and a height that is 21 cm higher (1.67 m).
The Tesla Model Y, on the other hand, has a sleek, streamlined design that aerodynamicsthe brand's hallmark. It is slightly shorter than the Seal U (4751 mm compared with 4775 mm), but wider (1921 mm compared with 1890 mm). The Tesla Model Y strikes a balance between spacious interior and fluid exterior design, giving it a sportier, less imposing appearance than the Seal.
On-board technologies and interior comfort: which model is the most innovative?
Both vehicles are at the cutting edge of technology, but offer different approaches to innovation and comfort.
The BYD Seal is distinguished by :
- A 15.6-inch rotating touchscreen on the dashboard
- A second screen of over 10.25 inches as a dashboard behind the steering wheel
- A Dynaudio Premium Sound HIFI system with a dozen powerful speakers
- Multicoloured ambient lighting for an immersive experience
The restyled Tesla Model Y offers :
- Ventilated front seats, a first for this model
- A new centre console with aluminium finish
- A steering wheel with customisable controls
- Improved connectivity with faster 50% download speeds and extended 30% range
- New low-emissivity glass reflects 26% of additional solar energy
- An intelligent MegaConsole between the front seats, offering plenty of storage space
In terms of innovation, the Tesla Model Y seems to have a slight edge, thanks in particular to its frequent remote updates and connected infotainment system. However, the BYD Seal also offers cutting-edge features that seriously rival Tesla's, particularly in the area of user experience and audio comfort.
Price and profitability: BYD Seal vs Tesla Model Y, which model offers the best value for money?
What is the price difference between the BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y?
Maintenance costs for electric vehicles are generally lower than for internal combustion vehicles, but there are differences between the BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y :
For the BYD Seal, specific information on maintenance costs in France is not available. However, BYD offers a generous warranty of 6 years or 150,000 km, or even 8 years and 200,000 km for the battery.
Tesla is renowned for its low maintenance costs. The Model Y benefits from frequent remote updates that can improve performance and add new features at no extra cost.
In terms of financial benefits :
- The standard Tesla Model Y is eligible for the €4,000 eco-bonus in France for households with an income per capita of less than or equal to €16,300, bringing the price down to €40,990.
- As the BYD Seal is produced in China, it is not currently eligible for the environmental bonus.
In terms of running costs, the Tesla Model Y appears to have a slight advantage in fuel efficiency, which could translate into long-term savings on recharging costs.
Our Tesla Model Y test drive
Verdict: BYD Seal or Tesla Model Y, which electric car should you choose?
Which model is best suited to drivers' needs?
For tech-savvy, performance-minded drivers, the Tesla Model Y is the obvious choice. Its AutopilotThe car's advanced technology, remote updates and semi-autonomous driving capabilities make it a vehicle for the future. Its capacity to seat up to 7 passengers and its giant 854-litre boot are perfect for dynamic families looking for versatility and cutting-edge technology.
The BYD Seal U is more suited to drivers looking for a well-balanced electric vehicle with good value for money. Its modern interior, top-of-the-range audio system and smoother ride will appeal to those who prefer on-board comfort to pure performance. Ideal for urban and suburban journeys, it represents a credible alternative for drivers wishing to go electric without investing in the most expensive models on the market.
Our BYD Seal test drive
Comparison of the key features of the BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y
| Features | BYD Seal | Tesla Model Y | Tesla Model Y Juniper 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| WLTP range | 420-500 km | Up to 600 km | 568 km |
| Acceleration 0-100 km/h | 5,9-9,6 s | 3,7-6,9 s | 4,3 s |
| Power | 218-324 hp | 299-534 hp | 299 hp |
| Battery capacity | 71.8-87 kWh | 60 kWh | 60 kWh |
| DC fast charge | 150-230 kW | 170-250 kW | 250 kW |
| Boot volume | 425-552 L | 854 L | 2138 L |
| Starting price | 45 390€ | 44 990€ | 60 990€ |
| Length | 4775 mm | 4751 mm | 4790 mm |
| Width | 1890 mm | 1921 mm | 1982 mm (mirrors folded down) |
| Height | 1670 mm | 1624 mm | 1624 mm |
| Consumption | 19.9-20.5 kWh/100km | 15.7-17.3 kWh/100km | 16.4 kWh/100km |
See also our article :
Conclusion
In conclusion, the choice between the BYD Seal and the Tesla Model Y depends on your priorities. The Tesla Model Y shines with its exceptional performance, advanced technology and generous interior space, ideal for those looking for dynamism and innovation. The BYD Seal, on the other hand, offers excellent value for money, superior driving comfort and an elegant design, perfect for urban journeys.
If you're an individual or a company looking to go electric or expand your electric fleet, whether you're looking to buy vehicles or install charging stations, Beev is here to help you with your project.
Use the TCO simulator to calculate the total cost of ownership of your car and compare it with its internal combustion equivalent.
