The problem of public charging points in France

Le problème des bornes de recharge publiques en France

France is encouraging the switch to electric vehicles, but there is still one obstacle on the road to mass adoption. public charging points. While their number increased significantly in 2023, their reliability and geographical distribution still leave something to be desired.

Read also : Charging stations: what's the current state of deployment? 

More and more charging stations are out of service or insufficient to meet growing demand. This reality highlights the obstacles faced by users of electric vehicles in our country. These circumstances pose a real challenge for around 20 % of French driversThis is especially true for those living in buildings in dense urban areas where there is no home connection. 

In short, thelack of a network of reliable, well-distributed terminals considerably complicates their transition to electric vehicles. 

In this article, we explore the various problems encountered with public charging points in France and propose solutions for a more peaceful future for electric vehicle drivers.

Table of contents

Find your future electric vehicle or charging point

BMW iX2 eDrive20

List price

46 990 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

453 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 478 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 8.6 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 30 minutes

Cupra Tavascan VZ

List price

46 990 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

602 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 517 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 5.6 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 28 min

VinFast VF 8 Plus Extended Range

List price

51 490 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

473 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 447 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 5.5 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 32 min

Mini Countryman E

List price

41 330 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

564 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 462 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 8.6 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 29 min

fiat e ducato profil

Fiat E-Ducato 79 kWh

List price

63 240 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

988 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 283 km

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 78 min

fiat e scudo profil

Fiat E-Scudo 50 kWh

List price

0 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

645 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 220 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 12.1 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 26 min

mercedes esprinter fourgon gris

Mercedes eSprinter Van 35 kWh

List price

75 972 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

655 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 153 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 11 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 26 min

citroen e berlingo van 3/4

Citroën ë-Berlingo Van 50 kWh

List price

40 440 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

599 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 275 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 9.7 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 26 min

Hyundai Inster Standard Range

List price

25 000 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

298 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 300 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 11.7 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 29 min

Opel Frontera 44 kWh

List price

29 000 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

491 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 305 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 12.1 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 32 min

Alpine A290 Electric 180 hp

List price

38 700 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

630 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 380 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 7.4 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 33 min

Fiat Grande Panda 44 kWh

List price

24 900 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

430 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 320 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 12 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 32 min

BMW i5 Touring eDrive40

List price

0 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

890 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 560 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 6.1 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 26 min

Tesla Model 3 Long Range Powertrain

List price

44 990 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

587 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 702 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 5.3 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 20 min

Mercedes EQE 300

List price

69 900 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

0 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 647 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 7.3 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 33 min

BMW i4 eDrive35

List price

57 550 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

607 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 483 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 6 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 32 min

Renault 4 E-Tech 40kWh 120hp

List price

29 990 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

448 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 322 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 9.2 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 32 min

Citroën ë-C4 54 kWh

List price

35 800 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

0 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 415 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 10 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 29 min

Volvo EX30 Single Motor ER

List price

43 300 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

436 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 480 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 5.3 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 28 min

Volkswagen iD.3 Pro S

List price

42 990 €

(excluding bonuses)

Lease from

0 €

Per month, with no deposit for professionals

Range (WLTP) : 549 km

Acceleration (0 to 100 km/h): 7.9 sec

Fast charge (from 20 to 80%) : 30 minutes

Beev offers you charging stations at the best prices!

Key figures for recharging solutions in France at the beginning of 2024

Since the start of 2024, 1,216 new stations have been added to the network, bringing the total to 5,338 new charging points accessible to the public.

There are currently 123,347 public charging points (Avere figures as at 29 February 2024). This month saw 3,002 new installationsequivalent to a growth of 2.49 %. In short, there is 183 recharging points per 100,000 inhabitants about.

Despite these encouraging figures, which demonstrate France's determination to develop electromobility, it should be noted that the evolution rate over 12 months fell below 40 % for the first time, reaching a level of increase of only 36 %. The availability of recharging points seems to be stabilising at the start of the year, after a steady decline in 2023, reaching 81 % in February 2024 for the AC current terminalswith disparities depending on the power of the terminals.

The graph below shows that the availability of DC charging points is lower than that of AC charging points (availability in %).

Le taux de disponibilité des points de recharge par mois et par catégorie de puissance

Source : Avere-France

Problems detected with charging stations in the region

Despite technological advances and a growing commitment to sustainable mobility, persistent problems are hampering the user experience. So what are the challenges facing the electric charging network in France? And what solutions are being considered to improve the accessibility and reliability of the electric charging network in France?

Increasingly frequent breakdowns

Recurrent breakdowns at public charging points are a major challenge for electric vehicle users. Despite efforts to extend the recharging network, statistics show that the number of outages is still very low. Alarming increase in breakdown incidentscompromising the reliability of the system.

As previously stated, Avere-France reassures us that availability would have reached 81 % in February 2024. In other words, 1 bollard in 5 remains out of serviceThis is a rare occurrence at the petrol pump, except in the event of industrial action.

Negative impact on users

On the one hand, companies dependent on fleets of electric vehiclescan be faced with operational delays and financial losses due to charging failures while on the move. These unplanned interruptions can adversely affect productivity and customer satisfaction.

On the other hand, drivers of electric cars for private use face major inconveniences on their daily journeys. Outages at charging points can lead to delaysand unscheduled journeys looking for alternative stations, and sometimes even emergency situations if recharging becomes impossible.

Our electrifying recommendations to overcome these problems

Terminal failures can be attributed to a variety of factors, such as :

  • acts of vandalism,
  • from technical problems,
  • a inadequate maintenance,
  • or a unresponsive after-sales service.

To solve these problems, it is essential to implement effective measures.

For example, it would be wise :

  • use preventive maintenance,
  • improve the monitoring and responsiveness of breakdown services,
  • raise awareness among users of the need to use recharging infrastructure responsibly.

Disparities in the distribution of charging points

France faces a major challenge when it comes to electric mobility: the uneven distribution of charging points across the country.

Although recharging solutions have been deployed in France, the number of terminals remains insufficient for drivers and thelack of a deployment strategy continues to vary from one region to another.

And with good reason: here are the current statistics showing the distribution of charging points by region (data updated to 29 February 2024).

RÉGIONS MÉTROPOLITAINES NOMBRE DE POINTS DE RECHARGE
Hauts-de-France
11 151
Normandy
6 634
Great East
11 853
Brittany
5 301
Île-de-France
21 412
Pays de la Loire
5 914
Centre-Val de Loire
5 156
Burgundy-Franche-Comté
4 850
New Aquitaine
11 998
Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes
14 484
Occitania
12 015
Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur
11 161
Corsica
802

On the other hand, here is a tabular summary of the overseas regions:

RÉGIONS D’OUTRE-MER NOMBRE DE POINTS DE RECHARGE
Guadeloupe
126
Martinique
154
French Guiana
44
La Réunion
292

Source : Avere-France

 

What's more, the majority of charging points deliver very low levels of power, so there's less waiting time between each car, and the charging points become overcrowded.

Source: Avere-France

 

As a reminder, the proportion of operational AC charging points is 81 %, 78 % for DC charging points delivering less than 150 kW and 77 % for more than 150 kW of power.

That said, 33 % deliver less than 7.4 kWequivalent to a household socket. Including the 7 and 22 kW charging points, which account for 50 % of charging points in the country, the figure rises to 83 %, an encouraging figure for motorists.

However, terminals with the appropriate flow rate (22 to 50 kW) only represent less than 15 %and rapids of more than 50 kW are almost non-existent, despite their renown.

Negative impact on users

This disparity can discourage private individuals considering a switch to electric vehicles. Indeed, theautonomy of electric vehicles, coupled with a heterogeneous recharging network, can create an obstacle for a feeling of insecurity for drivers on long journeys, for fear of not finding a terminal available.

For professionals with fleets of electric vehicles, this imbalance can also pose logistical problems. Route planning and recharging infrastructure must take account of the distribution of charging points, which can be complex in rural areas.

Our electrifying recommendations to overcome these problems

There are several possible solutions to these problems:

  • Speed up the deployment of charging points in rural and suburban areas.
  • Supporting the development of fast-charging stations so that vehicles can be recharged more quickly.

And if you want to plan an itinerary with your electric car so that you have access to all the charging points and their availability in real time, our article on the best route planners for electric cars may be of interest to you.

Electric car spaces snapped up by combustion-powered cars

Indeed, the spaces reserved for electric cars are increasingly coveted, given the exponential growth in eco-friendly vehicles over the last few decades. But that's not all, because a new problem is emerging: theoccupation of these spaces by combustion-powered vehiclesThis means that electric car users have no access to recharging. This phenomenon, known asICEd"This may or may not be intentional, but it is having a negative impact on the uptake of electric vehicles.

Negative impact on users

The relative scarcity of charging points, coupled with their occupation by non-electric vehicles, increases the time it takes to find an available point. This can be particularly stressful and frustrating for drivers on long journeys, which can lead to a loss of range for electric car drivers.

In addition, the uncertainty linked to the availability of the terminals may discourage motorists from considering a switch to electric vehicles.

Our electrifying recommendations to overcome these problems

It is important to remember the signage and the civic-minded parking in spaces reserved for recharging. Most major cities have introduced deterrent fines for poorly parked combustion-powered vehicles.


N.B. Thermal drivers risk a second-class fine of 35 euros (reduced to 22 euros and increased to 75 euros, and up to 150 euros in the event of a repeat offence).

bdr publique

The rise and disparities in the price of public recharging

As a reminder, this 1ᵉʳ February 2024the French Minister for the Economy, Bruno Le Maire, has confirmed that theincrease in electricity tariffsaffecting millions of French people.

This sudden rise is linked to the gradual end to the government tariff shieldto be implemented in October 2021 in response to the tensions in Ukraine.

Naturally, although home charging has an impact, charging at public charging points is also experiencing a slight upward trend, even though it is not subject to the same electricity tariffs. According to QovoltisThe cost of recharging an electric car for 100 km varies enormously depending on location, and can even quadruple. For example costs fluctuate between €2.5 and €10.6.

But that's not all pricing disparities of up to 800 % on a single terminal have been identified by the consumer association UFC-Que Choisir.

It should be noted that each operator sets its own rates, which are determined by various factors, including :

  • charges per minute,
  • the cost per kilowatt-hour,
  • parking charges,
  • the operator's fixed costs.

These aspects raise major challenges in terms of encouraging more private individuals and professionals to embrace green mobility.

Negative impact on users

The above points may affect electric vehicle drivers, particularly those who do not have the option of recharging at home. This may encourage some to postpone recharging, which is not a good idea. not optimal for battery health.

 

💡Did you know? It is recommended to maintain the battery charged between 20 % and 80 % to avoid damage caused by full charging cycles.

 

Users are feeling the direct financial impact of the rise in the price of public recharging. This increase can make recharging more expensive and less attractivewhich calls into question the economic viability of electric driving.

What's more, for many users, particularly those on lower incomes, higher prices may limit access to public recharging, thereby compromising the ability of carmakers to meet their needs. transition to electric mobility and exacerbating socio-economic inequalities.

Our electrifying recommendations to overcome these problems

For both private individuals and professionals with electric fleets, there are solutions for optimising recharging costs:

  • Compare rates terminal operators before plugging in your vehicle.
  • Favour home recharging during off-peak hours if you have the opportunity.
  • Take out a subscription with certain operators who offer low-cost monthly packages.

What's more, Beev offers a reload card giving access to over 300,000 charging points across Europe. It's free and commission-free.

Read also : The impact of rising electricity prices on my electric car

Conclusion

While France has made significant progress by installing More than 100,000 public charging points by May 2023and challenges remain for a smooth transition to electric vehicles. The fact that one charging point in five malfunctions and the uneven geographical distribution of charging points exacerbate the fear of running out of fuel. And let's not forget that there are an increasing number of charging point scams.

 

Read also : Charging station: the new QR code scam

 

Together, professionals and private individuals can transform the landscape of public charging points in France, offering a viable solution for electric vehicle drivers and encouraging widespread adoption of this eco-responsible technology. In short, managing the breakdowns of charging points requires a proactive and collaborative approach from authorities, network operators and users, to ensure a reliable and convenient recharging experience for all concerned.

 

By combining anticipation and action, we can contribute to a high-performance electric future that is accessible to all.

 

If you would like to find out more about the tax credit for in-car charging points  2024For more information, see our article on this subject.

Picture of Maëlle Laurent
Maëlle Laurent

Committed to sustainable mobility, a sector that is revolutionising the way we travel, I contribute to the energy transition through my articles.

With Beev

Switch to

or install your

For individuals and businesses

Discover our newsletter

Read also
Une femme confie ses clefs de voiture à un expert

With Beev

Switch to

or install your

For individuals and businesses